NOT MINE Someone needs to save this 1958 Fury

Clayboy

Member
FCBO Gold Member
Joined
Oct 29, 2022
Messages
98
Reaction score
53
Location
DMV
Feedback: 1 / 0 / 0
Came across this on a salvage reseller site. Obviously a write-off from recent hurricanes.

The “bad” thing about this site is the registration process requires you to put down a deposit as a condition of bidding. Also, there are a lot of fees, which can add up.

At least the site is transparent enough to provide a calculator so you can “what if” your bid(s) in order to get an idea of your final price.

Hope this helps finding it a new home or keep from being eventually parted out.

1958 Plymouth Fury For Sale in Riverview, FL Lot #75903***
 
Came across this on a salvage reseller site. Obviously a write-off from recent hurricanes.

The “bad” thing about this site is the registration process requires you to put down a deposit as a condition of bidding. Also, there are a lot of fees, which can add up.

At least the site is transparent enough to provide a calculator so you can “what if” your bid(s) in order to get an idea of your final price.

Hope this helps finding it a new home or keep from being eventually parted out.

1958 Plymouth Fury For Sale in Riverview, FL Lot #75903***
Water/flood damage, note the pic with the water line. Flood damage can be very difficult to detect and fix.

1734364117145.jpeg
 
Oh! Is that what "WL" means! Yikes, that sucks... still, a disassembly, thorough dry-out and clean-up and it can hopefully be saved!
 
1734364627909.png


Lotta views on flood cars.



Sorry, "story time" :poke:

My observation is people (just referring to myself) tend to UNDER-estimate, especially folks like me on the low-end of repair/refurbish PERSONAL skills. Most all of what I would need i gotta PAY others to do.

I only have ONE personal experience trying to rehab one (i.e., a flood car), but 100's of stories/anecdotes being in the OEM business/collecting hobby for decades. An occasional good news story in there, but most of these fairy tales end badly for the car.

At best vehicle aint ever "right" again, at worst its a financial fiasco, PLUS vehicle couldnt be saved in the end.

Of course, fresh vs. salt water, depth/length of immersion, clean water or polluted with sewage, chemicals, etc,. ALL plays a part, but ...:(. Most become just parts cars.

"Hard" parts" (sheet metal, aluminum, iron, etc) usually can be cleaned/refinished/reused), but if the innards are electrical/get corroded, it becomes dicey.

"Soft" parts (e.g,, door panels, seats, carpets, etc.,) NEVER (almost) can be salvaged. Sure, they (if not warped, de-lamed, etc.) can be dried, but they will always "smell" from bacteria/fungi that WILL return (even if, otherwise they "look" good).

Electrical? Most often, a total loss. Bigger issue with newer cars than older ones due to increased content in new stuff.

Insurance companies (assuming they are reputable) most times make rational, good-faith economic decisions given their business model . They (that industry) has literally millions of data points, from all over the world, all kinda vehicles, etc., that get flooded. Meaning their decisions tend yo have good fidelity taken from a large sample size.

And cost, by region of the floods for sure, to fix vs. premiums they collected. The economics tend to be clear.

We (in the OEM car biz) believe you me had our beefs with insurance companies, but our own testing of the stuff we built, tended to align with decision to scrap/total vs. fix. The repair effort, EVEN if remotely successful technically, would FAIL economically (and likely could compromise safety, on and on, etc.,)


LSS, dunno about this Fury. Dunno how good/bad it really is. Looks good though.

I can see it has "value" as it sits, even IF it is, TO ME, a "parts car" as its pretty complete. Some "Unobtainium" there it appears, and is a desirable collectors' item.. OTOH, it might be sufficiently rehabbed and could make somebody really happy (relative to whatever it transacts at).

Not really enough info disclosed about the circumstances before/after the "flood". That word sends ME running for exits for ANY car except "parts cars".

If that yellow sticky represents water level reached, perhaps most of the electrical/dash was spared. Carpet, seats, interior panels may be toast, though pictures look encouraging. Darn thing had 6+ inches of water in it .. old car, new car -- that concerns me.

TO ME, that would suggest its a least a parts car, or better yet it could be/in fact was rehabbed/made roadworthy at reasonable cost/success possibility.

Further, it aint on my "bucket list" in its own right, or as a donor for some other project. High sentimental value (it was my Dad's car or someting) would be the only thing that would make me take one of these on.

Not just a case of money per se .. which may be considerable (maybe already spent to get it to look this way?). Some things are just too far gone to try to bring back. Many flood cars fit that category.

This one?? Hope for the best, expect possibility of the worst. Recommend eyes/nose on, and butt in seat. Maybe even a spin around the auction yard if allowed. Good luck if anyone here chases it. :)

1734441229372.png
1734441249956.png
1734441285380.png
 
Last edited:
Not to mention, some insurance companies will not insure flood damaged or salvage cars, and branded titles are nearly impossible to resell.
 
The rugs, seats, wheels, etc. all look spectacular; would someone have cleaned it up this well just for a flood auction? Getting beige vinyl that clean after flooding wouldn't have been easy...
 
The rugs, seats, wheels, etc. all look spectacular; would someone have cleaned it up this well just for a flood auction? Getting beige vinyl that
clean after flooding wouldn't have been easy...

Note the dirty/rusty seat hinge cover. Now imagine what those harder to get to spots will look like. Tampa area got hit with a record hurricane this past year, so salt water/sewerage damage could be the issue. Check the car out, if it smells like Fabreeze, run away....

1734369459723.jpeg
 
Yeah, that bit of rust was the only thing I saw that looked odd. A professional restorer could probably tear the car down, clean-up/repair/replace what ails it, and sell it for a pretty good profit. Definitely not in my wheelhouse, but I admire those who can do so!
 
From the site - actual cash value 104, 000 USD. I would imagine that was the amount the car was insured for. If that's the case, I can understand why it's there. Most insurance companies will allow you to buy back your written off car. However at that price point, with all of the unknowns, re-registering a written off car and a lot of work ahead, I can understand why he would let it go.

I agree with amazingblue82, but I believe this one deserves some (alot) of elbow grease to see if it can't be saved.
 
I own a 1957. These cars have very basic wiring. I can't believe that car could not be saved. You can reach most inner panels too. It all would depend on the price it can be purchased for.
 
The wiring that is below the water line if correct, would be the power window wiring, breaker, maybe window motors, and the wiring towards the trunk so that's really no big deal. Need better photos of the door panels, if they are original they'd be moisture sponges. This is sad to see but I do hope it gets saved.. 350 Golden Commando equipped, add-on a/c, some electric goodies, and it's mostly complete. This sucks!
 
There's gotta be a reason someone put a lot of effort into it for clean up, then dumped it. I'm betting it stinks, parked with all the windows down. Maybe they don't work, but you would think they would be covered with crash wrap.
At the least, probably would need new seat foam, door cards, carpet; transmission and diff gone through, fuel system cleaned out. With any luck, the engine didn't get wet internally, unless water came in through the exhaust.
The electrical problems should be minimal, compared to a modern car.
 
Last edited:
The pic posted of the paper where the water line was shows the 1/4 panel, rocker, and door. There originally is a seam there so this car has been restored at some point.
 
Will be auctioned tommorrow:

Auction Location: Riverview, FL, USA
Sublot Location: CLEWISTON SUBLOT 4545 COUNTY ROAD 835 33440
Sale Name: FL - TAMPA SOUTH
Sale Date: Wednesday, December 18, 2024
Virtual Sale Time: 10:00 AM EST (GMT - 5:00)
 
Someone will buy this and save it.

Goodness, my dad’s Mazda B2000 was t boned/sideswiped while parked outside the house by a V8 Maverick that didn’t make the corner and he bought it and drove it for years.
 
I have a couple of windows still open on that Fury page, one says $13.6k and the other says $38750. That would have been maybe 10:30 am. Later at work on another computer I couldn't find the car on the auction site, I had to use the link in the first post, but it just said sold and didn't show a price. I'm not sure if it had a reserve, I guess it sold, at least close to $39k if not more.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top