Agree with Mr C above they are not the same wheel but they are dimensionally very similar. You mention a finned cover for the aluminum wheel (W23 in chart above) and that is perhaps a misunderstanding. What you call a finned cover is really several pieces. A bolt on finned, plastic, ring and a separate center cap assembly. I run the W23 aluminum wheels on my car with no bolt on finned trim ring nor the snap on trim ring from the steel wheel but either will fit and can be used. Likewise, the wheel centers, whether mopar or AMC all have the same mounting pattern. I am using notched? centers from 1st gen Cordoba urethane turbine wheels because they were very affordable and easy to locate compared to correct centers for the steel wheels. While the wheel center mounting patterns are all the same the aluminum wheel itself is threaded for a retaining ring to bolt to its face for the center cap to snap onto while the steel wheels just have holes for the attaching bolts to pass thru to thread into the wheel center. Help ? or more confused ?
View attachment 706378