I have a 74 dodge monaco its currently set up for a bigblock.
Im looking for a good honest 600-700 hp at the crank and about equal torque. Which is what my current car has.
I want it drivable so that leads to lower adders and maybe fuel injection.
Now we understand what you want to do and maybe we can help. Since you say current car has met the goals you state, perhaps you might share that with us.
If i just wanted a 400 hp engine then i would agree it is a bad idea.
I would just get another big block fuel inject it and be done.
It would be much easier.
With a heavy car, you need to start looking at a lot of factors. I see this all the time where high end horse power is the goal of the mods at the sacrifice of low end torque. You need low end torque to make a big car fast.
The ls motor meets all these specs much easier and it is the most swapped engine into all types of vehicles at this time.
I agree that it might meet the short term goals. I'm not convinced that in the long term it will be the right choice, but that's just my opinion.
So I said to myself maybe someone has done it already.So I came over here to see if anyone had and if so what knowledge I could gain.So I could decide if I wanted to or not.
Sorry, no one here seems to have done that. This forum and its participants focus on restoration and some simpler mods. It's not the HAMB or something like that. Don't expect "system knowledge" of such a swap when that's not what we do.
Unlike some people I have no brand ive owned almost all makes and models so if the ls is the best solution then unlike some I wouldnt get butthurt.
Now if its not then I won't.
I don't know as this is the best solution for you. The swap would entail fabricating engine and trans mounts. That's something I can do (and have done), but it does involve measuring, welding etc. Do you have the tools to do this? Any experience? This part is the honest to god, get your hands dirty and knuckles bleeding. Usually, guys that can do this work have already had the tape measure out and making notes.
Then you have to look at the car itself. What you have is 4500 lbs of car the designers never figured on having 700 HP. You have a front stub frame mounted in 42 year old rubber that you will have to deal with. At minimum you will want to eliminate the rubber and tie it to the rear frame rails. Again, this is more fabrication.
You'll have to deal with the rear end, most likely a 9" Ford rear would be the best choice. You might want to look at the geometry of the leaf springs as again, it's not designed to put 700 HP to the ground. Again, more fabrication.
You haven't mentioned what trans you want to run. It's going to be harder (obviously) to put a manual trans in the car. I'd look a hydraulic clutch pedal etc. An automatic is going to be easier, but the newer transmission might need some trans tunnel "massaging". If you're lucky, that just means hitting it with a Monday hammer in a couple spots. It also might mean fabricating or grafting in a new floor section.
Since you are going fast, now it becomes necessary to stop... At least that stuff might be "off the shelf".
So... It's obviously not a "bolt in" swap with a lot of work and sweat to do it right. If you can handle all that... or have the coins to have someone else do it, then, yea, go for it. Personally, I wouldn't do this with a 74 Monaco... but that's me.
If you wanted to lower your sights a little and still stay with a more modern driveline, then look at some of the modern Mopar engines. This has been done before and the conversion mounts are there to buy. It's still an unusual enough swap to grab some attention at the shows and cruise nights and should run pretty well.
I think we are aching for a well documented late model Mopar into a C body swap. If you want to go that direction, I think you'll have a lot of support here. Go with the Chevy, and expect to get more of what you got. Sorry... Look at the thread about the Toyota engined Dart for an example. It would require a thick skin and you won't get any more help.
I wish you luck.