My mistake. Syd did not die, just went a little haywire. I do realize that Gilmour's then girlfriend or fiance shared the writing credits of almost all the songs on the Division Bell, but many made the argument that a woman's contribution to the ideas and themes behind the album was a positive one. (apparently the label masters were not in that club) Still a favorite of mine.
No it wasn't just a contribution she was the sole creator of the lyrics and just didn't want credit on the album at all to stay out of the media controversy that was going on. She is a author of books(?) novels(?) children books(?), story teller she is, she fessed up to this in a interview lately and implied too it in a interview way back in 2015.
Something like at one time they needed lyrics to meet a deadline and she was sick and in her ill mutterings David wrote down what she was saying and when she read it after she was better, that David got it all wrong. LOL I think she says she writes the lyrics in her head as she's going for a walk listening to the final tracks on her headphones. Roger admitted David couldn't write lyrics to save his life, the band back then (all members) countered back with there is no pleasing Roger. But Roger is the maestro and was just trying to keep with the original content creator Syd's ideas.
Granted some of the shows Roger did were kind of blasé especially when he got booed up in Virginia railing on about Bush. I thought so too when I viewed the Coachella Concerts(?) Desert Trip I think it was called, yea you got the nice big wall screen Roger but the view is obscured by the hanging speaker towers (wtf) and when did Set The Controls For The Heart Of The Sun grow saxophones?
That show was a first good 720p show on YouTube rivaling the Candlestick Park very well edited multishot iPhone fan vid of Wall Version 2 and the multicam U2 Vegas show, but I thought one of the YouTube fan comments was very appropriate at the time. heh
Choose Life 1 year ago (edited)
Bad sound. Bad rent-a-band. Roger is old. Nice try. Largely wasted money.
To bad Gilmour wasn't helping. But Nick and David are beyond Roger actually.
The few regular musicians weren't at it either. And the SJW rant is so not there.
Everyone came for fun but Roger drags.
(Next show = no paid for nightmare.) Just a few million more $$ and Roger might be able to make good on the years of therapy.
So keep paying folks. Compassion pays the payer too.
Thanks but retire old man - you're real tired.
Now lets go to a real uplifting party....Adios ?
.