We have talked some about this before, but maybe it will help Stan (and others) see where I am coming from. In the early 90s, my early 20s self opened a defunct service station for the guy I had worked for on and off for several years. I had recently decided to pry my head out of my *** and get my career going as prior to this I hadn't really invested in tools or credentials. The Trooper who had taken over my district for PA safety inspection was famously the toughest prick in the whole state by all accounts... he took one look at me (23?, hair too long, baby face, shiny new inspection license) and decided it wasn't going to happen. He refused to allow the license based on the shop floor not being 1% grade or less and the business being closed long enough to not grandfather.
We had one flat bay, which was repoured as level as possible and he drug out the reinspection process for as long as he could. Paul, the owner, had some minor political connections and finally managed to get enough pressure on the trooper that he came and licensed the shop (he had a 6 month window, and had kept us back for almost 3).
PA safety inspection stations were supposed to get 2 audits a year. Unannounced the trooper shows up, gun, badge, light bar and walks in like any other cop... but this one can shut down the business on any infraction. I was audited openly 4 times that year, during 2 of which he watched me work on customer's cars and quizzed me (show me how to calibrate your headlight alignment tool, where is your ball joint gauge...). During that time the state police had an undercover team bringing cars in for inspection and they pulled the license from almost every Midas in the area. I was told later by a trusted source (different state trooper who was a customer) that I was investigated by this group twice.
I had to play anal retentive and straight and I knew I was under some scrutiny. I had many times when a "customer" brought in a car for inspection that I could see wouldn't pass. I would suggest the "less anal retentive" shop 5 miles away who had put stickers on several of my earlier cars and explain that if I brought it in this, this and this would fail and I would have to do a full inspection and charge them.
I ran that shop for about 3 years and as it got busier I wound up with 2 apprentices instead of another tech, the owner didn't want me knocking heads with someone older who thought they knew it all (and I think he was cheap). We were in the black the first year, and I think we could have done more with another full tech.
Funny thing... for the last year before I quit and moved to FL I received several job offers... when anybody talked to that trooper about finding good help to run their shop... my name seemed to come up. I also had 90 some % repeat customers because I didn't let myself get offended when they wanted explanations of the work required and I didn't gouge them.
I heard in 96, after the new emissions laws went in, that trooper went over to that part of enforcement and put a lot of shops out of the emissions program. By that time I was in FL being investigated by Chrysler to see if my warranty repairs were legit... 30k mile cars with check engine lights and ONE pin eased out of a PCM connector just enough to lose contact and held in place with some kind of glue. The guys at the training center knew me and knew about the investigation of the entity I worked for... came out of that good too.
Dave, PA safety may have become "mechanic's welfare" but it was a life or death situation for the businesses I ran/worked at when there... I heard from many techs that it all eased up after 96 and the emissions was the program that screwed them up. One former coworker was given an official warning because during an emissions test he saw a vacuum line off, and reconnected it. 10 minutes after passing the car on inspection he was in the service manager's office with the state boy asking how the car passed. The documented warning meant he couldn't have another occurrence within a period of time or lose his license, and possibly the businesses too. This in a GM dealership with a good reputation.
The Midas guys who got shut down either did faulty inspections and missed stuff, or oversold the car trying to make a paycheck... they deserved what they got. We had one next door at one location and did their inspections for about a year before they could get re-licensed. I also was somewhat involved in a state investigation that put a shop owner/tech into jail time. He was selling stickers to the used car lot next door. I inspected one of the sorriest cars you ever saw on the road with new stickers... I think the RO printed 4 pages of crap that failed. Luckily I wasn't pulled into court on that one... they brought it to me blind just to get an unbiased inspection.
Reality trained me to be an anal retentive prick about things being done right and CYA attitude. I bet the guy you let inspect your stuff never gets to touch it otherwise... and I believe it is kept in good shape and they try to find something... because there is almost always something. Even though you might like the going to the guy for an easy sticker... think what that indicates about the rest of his work.