If it's not a sealed unit, if it's been heavily discharged regularly you might need to add electrolyte- fill the cells with distilled water.
Thanks for the tip Ross. I actually check them yesterday and the water was at the right level. Your post yesterday made me think of my step-dad. He could always get around 10 years out of his batteries. He always has his batteries hooked up to a trickle charger when not running and told me to always check the water level at the beginning of the driving season and when ever I had a charging issue.If it's not a sealed unit, if it's been heavily discharged regularly you might need to add electrolyte- fill the cells with distilled water.
I only have a few more weeks of driving season. I will probably just wait until next spring at this point. The boat is coming off the water this week so I will have it as a back up, if the battery ends up being toast.
Problem solved thanks everyone for input, it was the voltage regulator. When I hooked up my voltmeter with my back-up battery it read 12.6 before I started, 12.2 with the engine running. I hooked up the new VR I had on the shelf it read 13.9 to 14.0. The gauge is reading right where it has in the past too. I turned my headlights on and the needle didn't budge, before I switched out the VR it actually dropped below center. I never took that reading with the voltmeter.
The bonus is I don't have to decide what kind of battery to buy at this time. I got my old one to take a charge today, it's days could be numbered but the voltage numbers were good. I got 12.8 volts at rest and 14.0 while running.