well i depends what gear is in it? the 72 318's was smogged out they cut the compression while a 70 318 in a dart with 3.23 gears would get 20 MPGs but it made more horse too (235 veris 190 in 72) IN A 3800-4000# B BODY THE 66 318 GOT 15 + MPGs it has to due with & hp. putting a smog 318 in the older car was ok but rebuilding the factory motor would had been better . & how many miles r on it iit its 50k i bet it needs valve seals & if its close to 90-100k then its timing chain time put a double row one in u will never have to replace it . if u dont when it throws the chain & it will then it will bend every valve in the motor costing u way more . how mechanical inclined r u ? can u tear the motor down & rebuild it?