My goal was another step in tidying my engine bay with increased performance being a bonus. I have experience with a 318 Poly engine in a 1960 Dodge Phoenix ( with after market ignition, Bosch style distributor with BIM024 module and Procomp e-core coil) which has reliably taken us on >1000km journeys throughout coastal and inland Queensland Australia in temperatures above 100F.
That setup I could not find for my 383 Polara but with the designed2drive/Moparmat2000 setup I am confidant using these commonly found parts, subject to suitable coil we will again be good to go.
I meant no disrespect to the work you or Moparmat2000 have done. There seems to be a trend among those who find ignition systems to be mysterious that newer, bigger, more is going to equal better and solve all of their problems (like a worn engine). My posts might help them reconsider.
I dislike much of what is see sold as an improvement, and believe much of it is a move backwards. If I was interested in redesigning the ignition, I liked the GM truck coil/module/bracket from Big_John's post... I have had very good luck with them (2 in the driveway) and parts should be readily available if you do need them.
For WIW, I believe the GM 4 pin module has about as much failure rate as the Chrysler module and is sensitive to heat sink issues even more so. They both seem to have the same low quality replacements out there now, maybe the GM is a bit more available. Still likely to be zero gain over stock on a factory engine.
I struggle to understand MSD use on naturally aspirated engines. I do understand increasing burn time for forced induction.
Hey look everyone I redesigned the wheel and it's still round.
Thank you
I've been kind of hoping I'd hear some downsides from someone like yourself. It's usually something about "I'm not putting GM parts..." rather than experience and logic.
Thank you John. I'm sure half the readers of this post will still want to work too hard to get similar results, at best, as they would get just making everything they have right.
The real reason I entertain the idea that a modified ignition, or change to Chrysler electronic ignition from points, is the quality of replacement parts declining and becoming more difficult to find. I don't think we are all the way there yet, but I can see a possibility that the next decade or two won't be kinder to many old parts brands and the constant change of manufacturing locations doesn't help keep old stuff alive.
The big brands have been killing the industry... they make it hard to find parts that are still in the catalog because they don't have enough sales volume. Around here, I am almost out of mom and pop part stores.